I've worked from home most of my 11 years at Oracle so I'm probably not the best person to speak here but...I have spent several weeks in various Oracle APAC offices (Singapore, Sidney, Melbourne, Seoul) which have this type of open space design in one form or another. For the most part, general work isn't too bad, but anytime you actually have to talk on the phone it is a nightmare as there are some 20 or so conversations going on around you at any given time. To me it just seems to push people to be less interested in speaking with someone and more inclined to use various other forms of communication, i.e. email, IM, SMS, etc. I guess that would make open space offices more Web 2.0ish. Is that a good thing?
jack
Jake
· 2 years ago
Yeah, open spaces make for newsroom or trading bullpen like noise levels. Not good. We do so much teleconferencing and there are a small number of conference rooms, so I can't imagine how this is workable.
The lack of silence for concentration thing is what I think is the worst part.
Jake
John Flack
· 2 years ago
Joel Spolsky has an article on his observations about the way to get the best out of software developers. Read it at http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/FieldGui.... In his opinion, going from a cube farm to an open design is a step in the wrong direction. I'm inclined to agree. I have a semi-private office that I share with someone whose schedule overlaps mine by only four hours a day. Yet I'd gladly trade my semi-private with a window for a truly private office, even windowless. I want to be able to close my door and shut out the rest of the world when I'm concentrating hard on a tricky piece of code. I used to be in a cube, and it was worse - very hard to get anything done.
Jake
· 2 years ago
Totally agreed. Someone needs to build a cheap, modular office pod, like a cube with a door and ceiling. Just like the itty-bitty, narrow offices in Brazil (the movie, not the country), minus the shared table. Add some open areas for bullpen style work and socializing, and you're good to go.
Tim
· 2 years ago
When I worked in the UK offiecs way abck when it was all open plan. My memories may be rose tinted but it was awesome. We were a real 'tight' team and got things done and the openess allowed you to interact with team mates, bouncing ideas, etc. If you wanted peace - get some headphones. Telephone calls were a little tougher but not that bad. Coming to cube city in HQ was a shock to the system - suddenly no one talked to you - very quiet. I used to make a point of getting up and walking around to have a chat with folks in distant cubes. I seem to remember bugging the heck out of you Jake - maybe it was the other way round :)
Jake
· 2 years ago
Tim sat over the cube farm wall from me at corporate in 300 on the 12th floor for several years. Socializing is part of the office experience. I just like the option for silent concentration when I need it. Each has its place.
Meg
· 2 years ago
Jake, don't forget you would also need to shower to come into an office. Just shaving and combing your hair would not be sufficient.
Jake
· 2 years ago
Showering is a global parameter. I was talking about things I don't do every day anyway, i.e. shave, fix hair, wear big boy clothes.
All Comments
I've worked from home most of my 11 years at Oracle so I'm probably not the best person to speak here but...I have spent several weeks in various Oracle APAC offices (Singapore, Sidney, Melbourne, Seoul) which have this type of open space design in one form or another. For the most part, general work isn't too bad, but anytime you actually have to talk on the phone it is a nightmare as there are some 20 or so conversations going on around you at any given time. To me it just seems to push people to be less interested in speaking with someone and more inclined to use various other forms of communication, i.e. email, IM, SMS, etc. I guess that would make open space offices more Web 2.0ish. Is that a good thing?
jack
The lack of silence for concentration thing is what I think is the worst part.
Jake
Just like the itty-bitty, narrow offices in Brazil (the movie, not the country), minus the shared table.
Add some open areas for bullpen style work and socializing, and you're good to go.
Coming to cube city in HQ was a shock to the system - suddenly no one talked to you - very quiet. I used to make a point of getting up and walking around to have a chat with folks in distant cubes. I seem to remember bugging the heck out of you Jake - maybe it was the other way round :)
Socializing is part of the office experience. I just like the option for silent concentration when I need it.
Each has its place.